From Battling the Bureaucrats
Read an Excerpt
The opening pages of Amy Siple’s story, in her own words.
I knew in my heart it was cancer, but the news terrified me nonetheless. How could these multiplying microscopic cells threaten my favorite human? His 6’5” 235 lb muscle bound frame looked indestructible, but I knew the truth. As a nurse practitioner for over 32 years, I had seen it before. Cancer was a serious and relentless contender and could take out the mightiest of men. We would need to be a unified force.
It was late 2023, and as fate would have it, the practice I had been employed with for almost 20 years sold out to a large corporation around the time of my husband’s diagnosis. The timing was right to take a step away from practice as we began navigating the metastatic cancer journey. Through 33 years of marriage, we had traversed lots of challenges, but this one was different. We had attended funerals of many of his firefighter colleagues who had lost their battle with cancer. Fear was taking a hold of me.
Hope was restored over the next few months following a successful surgery. Cancer markers were declining and it was time to return to work. The six months that I had stayed home were a welcome break, but I missed the connections with my patients and the income. I had a God-given heart for those in need and I cared for an under-served population. Head hunters were messaging me. My heart ached to consider all the older adults in my community suffering from a lack of access to care. This was a problem I was well suited to assist with.
On October 27, 2024, prior to applying for positions, I decided to check the board of nursing’s website. Like most nurses, I only visit this site when it is time to renew my license. It was an even numbered year, so I knew it was my time to renew but, honestly, could not remember if I had completed the process. The past 6 months had been a bit of a blur. Much to my dismay, the website revealed I had failed to renew my license almost 5 months earlier.1 This was the first time in 32 years that I failed to meet the deadline. My record with the board of nursing was completely clean with no history of lawsuits or complaints filed. I was sure it would be a simple process to get my license reinstated. After all, my continuing education requirements were met prior to my deadline (May 31, 2024) and my malpractice insurance had never lapsed. This was only a matter of late payment of dues. My assumptions could not have been further from the truth. My nightmare journey with the board of nursing had just been birthed.
Evan Faulkner with KSBN emailed me asking about my last day to work as an NP with Wichita Medical Associates, my former employer. I responded with, “Thank you for reaching out. That information self-populated and I did not have a way to correct it (it was grayed out on the renewal form). I worked for Wichita Medical Associates from 2005-2023. I now see clients under my own license. I have been doing this pro bono.”2
After hitting send I realized I should not have used the word “client.” I was caring for family and friends only. I clarified this with the KSBN. There is a provision for this type of care for unlicensed nurses in the nurse practice act in K.S.A. 65-1124.
Family and close friends I know who are ill often reach out to me. I had been going into their homes, the hospital, or encouraging them through phone calls. I am simply supporting, encouraging, and offering counsel. I refer them back to their primary care providers with suggestions, bring them meals, pick up their meds…I think it is hard to classify this as practicing as a nurse practitioner. I am simply acting as a Christian. I am not paid for this service and no billing has occurred under my NPI numbers since 2023.
On November 4, Evan Faulkner emailed, “I have scoped out your website and I am seeing you’re an educator and speaker. Have you done any presentations since your license lapsed on 5/31/2024?”3
I called and told him I had recently delivered a free presentation at a local senior center regarding “Understanding Dementia and Caring for those Who Have It.” I said I didn’t understand the nature of the question. He stated I was not qualified to speak when my license had lapsed.
I challenged this, saying, “my knowledge level did not change because I was late in paying KSBN. I am helping people and I am very qualified through years of experience to do so.” I confirmed with him that all my CNE were acquired prior to my license expiration deadline. I also relayed I am certified by ANCC and GAPNA, which require more stringent criteria than KSBN. I was faulty in paying on time by 4 1/2 months, but this was the only thing I was guilty of. I have never been sued and no complaints have ever been filed against me.
Evan told me I should hear back regarding a decision that week. I requested an opportunity to present my case before board members. He said my case had already been sent to them.
I kept thinking,
“They don’t understand.”
“No patients were harmed.”
“I just owe you money, right? Just a late fee?”
I thought if I could explain what happened, they’d understand. I’d never been in trouble. I just… I didn’t understand it was really real. I kept trying to contact more people because I thought I could explain it.
I had worked with the executive director, Carol Moreland, and one of the board members, Melissa Orpeza, on KSBN in the past and reached out to them. I did not hear back from either.
On November 7, I checked KSBN’s website and noted they had not renewed my license although they had accepted my payments on October 27. I was scheduled to speak for an organization that day and called to inform them I was not currently licensed.
I received a letter on Saturday, November 9 (dated November 6) stating my case was transferred to KSBN’s legal counsel and that I could contact KSBN’s legal counsel.4 On Monday, I left messages in both the morning and afternoon and did not receive a call back. I reached someone the next day, but they acted evasive and said I would hear something in a couple of weeks.
On November 12, I submitted a KORA request for all information regarding my case. On Friday, November 15, I received an email notification that my KORA request was denied because there was a current investigation.5
The whole process was so frustrating and challenging because I didn’t know how to defend myself without understanding what the board meant by “practicing without a license.”
I didn’t realize they were actually coming after me until Thanksgiving week.
Saturday morning (November 23), the north wind bit at my face as my hair flew in all directions. I slid an envelope from the mailbox and didn’t wait for the walk back into the house before I ripped open the letter from KSBN.
At first relief washes over me. It starts by saying that my case has been reviewed and KSBN isn’t ordering any action. Instead, they’ve included a consent agreement for us to resolve my case and move forward.6 I have 14 days from the date of the letter, which was November 18, five days earlier. If it took five days to get here, I’d have to mail it back in four days, which was Thanksgiving, so that wouldn’t work. I’d need to return it through a faster means like email.
Then I read, “Failure to return the Agreement within 14 days will be considered your rejection of the offer and Disciplinary Counsel will proceed accordingly.”7 It was written in italics, too. In the middle of the letter.
I’m sure I gasped, though no one was around to hear me. Was that a threat to seek additional sanctions against my license? Sounded like one.
I read the consent agreement all the way through, but I returned to the paragraph that stated I agreed that I had practiced without a license and was guilty of unprofessional conduct.8 I still didn’t understand why the KSBN thought I had practiced nursing during my license lapse. Nor did I know what unprofessional conduct meant.
If I signed, I would have to report the discipline on any future renewal or reinstatement applications and that the agreement would go in a permanent disciplinary file.
Paragraph 21 ended: “The Agreement and Order will be reported as required by state and federal law.”9 What exactly did that mean?
Hours of research later, I had my answer. I would be reported on three national databases for Unprofessional Conduct: Practicing without a license. And my name would never be removed.
I didn’t understand why.
God had used my role as a nurse and nurse practitioner to help thousands of clients through the years. It was unbelievable to be faced with such excessive disciplinary action by the KSBN. I was happy to pay any fines they wanted to level against me. But being labeled with “unprofessional conduct” was egregious. Their intent to place my name and address on their website with this designation and to report me to a National Practitioner Database could impact my ability to run for public office, impact my malpractice insurance rates, or my ability to seek future employment.
I had been a tenured professor and spoken at commencement, served as the president of the Kansas Advanced Practice Nurses Association and was instrumental in getting full practice authority passed for APRNs in Kansas, served as the Chair of the Kansas Board for Adult Care Home Executives, and in 2023 I was given the AANP (American Association of Nurse Practitioners) state award for excellence. In 2024, the same year I was accused of practicing without a license, I received the Healthcare Hero Award from the Wichita Business Journal.
Now, I didn’t know what I faced. I was scared and panicky and didn’t know what to do.
My husband walked in the room and sensing my tension asked me what was wrong. I broke down crying and handed him the letter. I could see the frustration on his face but he remained ever calm and said this should not surprise us based on their responses thus far.
“God has a plan in all of this. Let’s pray.”
Pray.
Why didn’t I start with that. My favorite verse is Prov 3:5-6 “Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding. In all your ways acknowledge him and he will direct your paths.” Yet here again, I am leaning on my own understanding and not turning to Him in this hour of need. We prayed but I did not surrender the problem. In all honesty I was distracted during his prayer thinking about what else I needed to do.
I had connections with the Kansas Justice Institute and Americans for Prosperity, so I reached out, completed an application, and asked them to take my case.
Since they won’t take on a client who has another attorney, I waited to hear back, with the mounting pressure that each day passing shortened my time for a response to the KSBN.
Meanwhile, family was coming for Thanksgiving. We had 26 come that year. I’m trying to cook. I’m trying to clean. I’m trying to get everything ready. I didn’t know how to talk about it. I didn’t know who to talk about it to. The first family member I approached told me to stop being prideful and sign the consent agreement. After that, I only shared it with my husband and my mom. I didn’t want to burden my family with it because I didn’t even know how to explain what was happening. I didn’t understand it myself.
I stressed. Overwhelmed. I’m not sleeping. My mind is constantly working on the problem; racing all the time. I couldn’t eat. I felt awful.
There is a walking path at our house through the trees. I’d go alone, walk, pray, and cry out loud, “God, help me!”
I was already stressed before this. The pathology report revealed the cancer had metastasized out of his prostate and was traveling down the nerves. Firemen are high risk for cancer in general, but particularly genitourinary cancer secondary to the toxins they’re exposed to. We were waiting on the most recent PSA numbers post-surgery and praying for the best.
I realized I might need to support us financially, and my ability to do that was completely dependent on my nursing license. What am I going to do? Start over at my age? Doing what? You build all this, but then it’s completely dependent on the state saying that you can practice your profession.
During one walk, I remembered a conversation Scott and I had a few years prior.
“I don’t know why we need life insurance,” I told him.
He was a captain on the fire department and had a successful home inspection business. I taught, spoke at conferences, and worked as a nurse practitioner. We both had multiple skills and I thought if one of us died, the other would be able to support themselves.
“Yeah, you’re right,” Scott agreed. “Let’s just get rid of life insurance.”
We clicked along having no idea how prideful we had been or that the Lord was about to show us how we depended on ourselves instead of on Him.
Boom! It’s gone. Scott has cancer, can’t work at his business, and retires from the fire department. Then my license is taken away. I never envisioned that could happen.
I finally hear back from the Kansas Justice Institute on Friday after Thanksgiving; an email stating they’re not taking my case.
I called my mom from my son’s house in Wamego—poor service; spotty calls.
“I need to find an attorney.”
One business day remained until KSBN expected an answer.
She’s calling around. I’m calling around. I can’t get good cell service. I’m sitting outside in the cold praying for the Lord’s intervention.
Finally, at about 4:45, I make contact with Josh Ney. He’d never handled a Board of Nursing case or licensing boards before, but he was an administrative law attorney. And he could meet with me on Monday morning.
Then he told me his rate.
I hung up feeling like I was so backed into a corner.
I wasn’t ready to sign the consent agreement, but we couldn’t afford an attorney for long.
Scott simply said, “Don’t sign it.”
I said to him, “Four hundred fifty dollars an hour? You can’t even work right now because of surgery. What are we going to do?”
Scott looked at me with those trusting eyes that captured me in college and never let go. He’s the most honest man I know, and he’s always supported me in everything. When he gave his life to Christ, he was all in. So many times, so many times he has provided faith when I felt weak. This was one of those times, because now, like always, he didn’t, and wouldn’t, waver.
He leaned down and placed his forehead against mine. I closed my eyes and savored his closeness. That alone gave me assurance. But not as much as his next words would provide. “God will take care of it. Don’t sign it.”
* * *
What Happens Next?
Amy refused to sign. Read the full story of how one nurse’s stand became a movement for reform. Pre-order now through January 1, 2027 to receive a signed copy.
Notes
- Kansas State Board of Nursing licensure and renewal records for Amy Siple (copy in authors’ possession). ↩
- Email correspondence between Evan Faulkner and Amy Siple regarding her license renewal investigation, Oct. 2024 (copies in authors’ possession). ↩
- Email from Evan Faulkner to Amy Siple, Nov. 4, 2024 (copy in authors’ possession). ↩
- Kansas State Board of Nursing letter to Amy Siple, Nov. 6, 2024 (copy in authors’ possession). ↩
- Amy Siple, Kansas Open Records Act request, Nov. 12, 2024; Kansas State Board of Nursing response, Nov. 15, 2024 (copies in authors’ possession). ↩
- Kansas State Board of Nursing, proposed Consent Agreement and Order for Amy Siple, Nov. 18, 2024 (copy in authors’ possession). ↩
- KSBN, proposed Consent Agreement and Order for Siple, Nov. 18, 2024. ↩
- KSBN, proposed Consent Agreement and Order for Siple, Nov. 18, 2024. ↩
- KSBN, proposed Consent Agreement and Order for Siple, Nov. 18, 2024, para. 21. ↩